Sign up to SCR Digest, our FREE weekly newsletter, and receive our Notes emailed directly to you.
Email Address *
First Name
Mailing Lists *

PBSV: Very Strong Q1 Results. Rapid Recovery from Hurricanes, Ramping European Consulting Activity

By Brian Marckx, CFA


Fiscal Q1 2018 Results…

Pharma-Bio Serv (OTC:PBSV) reported financial results for their fiscal first quarter 2018 ending January 31st. Results were relatively extremely strong, particularly considering the massive destruction that Puerto Rico suffered from two hurricanes that made landfall on the island in September (i.e. ~mid-fiscal Q4 ’17) and caused damage estimated at over $100B (see our hurricane overview in Appendix for more background). And the quicker-than-anticipated recovery from the storms was not the only highlight in Q1, which also saw a rebound in gross margin and much lower operating expenses. The combination pushed operating income into the black for the first time in the last seven consecutive quarters (i.e. since fiscal Q2 2016, ending April 2016).

Despite widespread damage, including island-wide power loss, PBSV weathered the storms relatively extremely well and was operational within just days. That ability to quickly resume operations was apparent in the fiscal Q4 2017 (ending October 31) results – which showed only a 9% sequential decrease in PR consulting revenue. While lab revenue fell by a much more significant 41% from Q3 to Q4 2017, based on the Q1 ’18 numbers, PR-related revenue (both consulting and lab-related) has now almost already rebounded to fiscal 2017 levels.

Certainly, the critical nature of Puerto Rico’s pharmaceutical industry on the mainland U.S. and PBSV’s reputation as one of the industry’s top service providers bodes well for a rapid recovery in the company’s operations and revenue – particularly as it relates to their lab and PR consulting business. And with the expectation that results will continue to benefit as the island further recovers, we think PR consulting and lab revenues will exhibit additional growth throughout 2018. With PR-related operations recovering quicker than we had anticipated, we have made substantive upward revisions to our revenue estimates.

Q1 2018 revenue was $4.2M, 4% better than the year-earlier period and 16% higher than Q4 2017. In fact Q1 2018 revenue was higher than any quarter in 2017. All of the yoy growth and most of the sequential growth relates to a recent significant jump in consulting activity in Europe, which was also a bright spot in Q4 ’17 and a territory that likely represents a substantial growth opportunity. And while every other territory showed a yoy decline in Q1 ’18, all major geographies and lab operations posted growth on a sequential basis.

PR consulting has come back strong, with related revenue ticking up 5% from the prior quarter to $2.7M and well ahead of our $2.3M estimate. As a reminder, management recently indicated that they expected to PR consulting (and lab operations) to return to historical levels – with the implication also that that could happen fairly rapidly. Clearly the Q1 ’18 numbers support that theme. We are now forecasting consistent sequential growth of PR consulting revenue throughout 2018 and model positive revenue growth for the full-year revenue.

U.S. consulting revenue was $287k in Q1, down 17% yoy but 42% better than Q4 ’17 – which, at just $202k in revenue, was the weakest U.S. consulting quarterly sales number since at least Q1 2011 (i.e. the farthest back that we looked). The sequential growth is somewhat encouraging as while we do not have specific insight into the recent significant weakness, we do not think the hurricanes (which also hit parts of the U.S. mainland) are to blame and think it may be mostly project-timing related.

As a reminder, the company recently shuttered two U.S.-based offices (in PA and CA) as part of its recently implemented "streamlined business development approach". Importantly, these were leased (sales-oriented) offices and PBSV's business model and time-and-material contracts means opportunistically re-ramping can be achieved on a relatively short time frame. But, it may be too early to predict a sustained recovery in U.S. sales, particularly given our lack of any detailed project-related insight. However, PBSV has been opportunistic in the past and we expect they will continue to be so. Additionally, PBSV has been considering the use of remote facilities in the U.S., which could provide the benefits of lower cost and even greater flexibility. The company recently mentioned that, having recovered from the hurricanes, that they can now focus more attention on the U.S. consulting strategy. Importantly, expense-containment efforts, including closure of satellite offices, have helped to push down operating expenses to near historically-low levels and resulted in significant improvement in overall profitability.

Clearly encouraging was management’s mention shortly after the hurricanes passed that their European and Americas-based operations were fully operational. European operations recently began providing assistance to the workforce in Puerto Rico, which we think reflects the relatively massive jump in revenue from that territory beginning in Q4 ‘17. For some historical context, over the ten-quarter period from Q2 2015 – Q3 2017 European consulting revenue averaged $211k per quarter, and never breached $300k. Since then, European consulting turned in $512k in Q4 ’17 (+114% yoy, +138% qoq) and $721k in Q1 ’18 (+295% yoy, 41% qoq) – with the most recent quarter also marking the highest level of sales from this segment since Q4 2013. Indications are that Europe could remain strong as a result of new consulting opportunities there. Importantly, European consulting is also driving operating profitability – while every other major itemized territory/segment was in the red in both Q4 ’17 and Q1 ‘18, European consulting contributed six-digit profit during both periods (i.e. $107k in Q4 ’17 and $222k in Q1 ’18) and was a major reason why total operating income was back in the black in Q1 (the first time since Q2 ’16). As such, continued relatively strong sales from this region could continue to benefit the bottom line and cash flow.

Similar to the company’s Puerto Rico-based consulting operations, activity in their lab segment (also located in Puerto Rico) was disrupted by the hurricanes – which also showed up in the related revenue – falling from $528k in Q3 ’17 to $311k (-41%) in Q4 ’17, the lowest level since Q4 2012. About one-half of that qoq decline was attributed to the storms. PBSV had previously indicated that while some property damage repairs were required, that their lab (and other facilities in Puerto Rico) did not suffer any structural damage – and also implied that (similar to PR consulting) lab activity and revenue should return to more normal levels.

Encouragingly, it looks like that’s already happening as lab revenue increased 54% from the final period in fiscal 2017 to $479k in Q1 ’18. As noted, the recovery was much swifter than we had expected – evidenced by Q1 lab revenue’s big beat to our $243k estimate. The faster and more robust recovery has prompted upward revisions to our forecasted lab-related revenue. And while the Q1 level was not enough to fully cover fixed-lab related expenses (lab operating loss was $107k in Q1), this segment affords much more scalability (than does most pure consulting projects) at incrementally higher levels and as such, offers the possibility of relatively outsized contribution to operating income. So, if lab activity continues to pick up, that could benefit overall operating income.

Relative to expenses and operating income…as consulting-related activity waned, PBSV recently began implementation of some right-sizing measures aimed at leveling operational capacity to that of market demand and activity. These cost-cutting measures, which included headcount reduction in certain support and sales areas, as well as closure of non-core offices, have significantly reduced operating expenses. OpEx dropped from $1.42M in Q1 2017 to just $1.06M in Q1 2018 – a decrease of 25%. Importantly, these initiatives have not come at the cost of revenue growth. Over the same period revenue increased by 4% - the net result was operating expenses as a percentage of revenue falling from 35% to 25%. This is the lowest level (as a percent of revenue) since Q4 2015 and a major impetus to PBSV eking out 19k of positive operating income in Q1. OpEx levels will be something to keep an eye on, given its obvious importance to profitability – even very incremental revenue scaling at these OpEx levels can result in a fairly dramatic benefit to operating income.

Meanwhile, gross margin, also showed some recovery from the 16.8% level in Q4 2017 – as a reminder, the hurricanes were responsible for shaving about 570 bp off GM in that quarter. Q1 GM, at 25.7% is inline with the average in 1H 2017, although still well below the ~30% level average in 2016 (on $19.5M in revenue). While GM may show some short-term variability, we think it expands with revenue growth and currently model full-year 2018 GM of 25.5%, compared to 23.2% in 2017.

In terms of liquidity, PBSV continues to maintain a solid balance sheet and cash position. Cash balance was $13.2M at fiscal Q1 quarter-end – which is an increase of $1.4M from $11.8M at the end of fiscal 2017. The increase mostly relates to $1.3M decrease (i.e. collection) of accounts receivable. Operating cash flow was $1.5M in Q1 – and even if excluding changes in working capital, operating cash flow was still a positive $203k. PBSV recorded a $2.7M income tax liability (which was disclosed in the 2017 10-K and which we explained in our prior update) in Q1 related to recent changes to U.S. income tax treatment of subsidiaries’ earnings and profits. This $2.7M relates to accumulated (i.e. prior years’) undistributed earnings and profits of their Puerto Rican subsidiaries. It is payable over eight years (8% yrs 1 – 5, 15% yr 6, 20% yr 7 and 25% yr 8) beginning in February 2019. PBSV expects to fund it with working capital.

Given the sizeable cash balance and our forecast of improving cash flow, we have no concerns about the company’s liquidity position. Cash balance could benefit further from potential insurance recoveries. As a reminder, PBSV previously noted that as of the end of fiscal Q4 (i.e. October 31, 2017) approximately $50k in property damage-mitigation repairs had been made and Q4 gross profit was negatively impacted (from lost sales) by ~$275k. The company further noted, as it relates to potential insurance recoveries, that the “Company carries insurance to mitigate these losses, as well as for property damages.” And, per the Q1 10-Q, “The Company’s insurance provider is currently assessing the extent of the damages to the facilities, as well as the business interruption losses and additional expenses incurred by the Company until electrical power and other basic utilities were restored [November 22, 2017]. Based on current accounting guidance, the insurance proceeds will be recognized upon collection, as a gain contingency.”

Outlook / Valuation:

PBSV Rapidly Recovering From Hurricanes…
Hurricane Maria slammed Puerto Rico on September 20, 2017, causing massive and widespread destruction throughout the island that is estimated at more than $100B. Despite the devastation, PBSV was able to resume operations in Puerto Rico within about one week after Hurricane Maria made landfall. Fortunately, the company did not suffer significant damage to their facilities or to personnel. Given the size and strength of the hurricanes, the direct hit on the island and overall massive destruction that they caused, we were surprised by the relatively minor impact to Q4 financial results as well as the already rapid recovery as evidenced by the Q1 ’18 numbers. The reason, in large part, is likely related to not only PBSV’s ability to quickly resume operations (via generator power) but also of their P.R.-located clients’ ability to do the same. We also think the robustness and speed of the initial recovery bodes well for further rebound in P.R. consulting and lab activity and related revenue throughout the remainder of 2018.

Europe is where we think the bulk of the very near-term growth opportunity lies. Indications are that Europe could remain strong as a result of new consulting opportunities there. And while U.S. consulting has been soft as of late, indications are that PBSV is now able to dedicate a greater focus on finding new opportunities there. Shuttering their two U.S.-based offices has helped with cost-control and the use of remote facilities should allow greater flexibility.

Other potential growth-related opportunities include their new Calibrations division (“Metrologix”) in Puerto Rico (development of which was completed in Oct 2017), Pharma-Brazil and, possibly, entry into Cuba. Pharma-Brazil is a wholly-owned subsidiary which PBSV registered in 2015 in order to provide consulting services to the Brazilian market. Given the historical strength (until recently) in Latin America-related project demand and revenue, this area of the world, including Brazil, could offer meaningful growth opportunity for PBSV.

Relative to Cuba, in December 2016 PBSV obtained a license from the U.S. Dept of Treasury Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) authorizing the company to perform certain services and transactions with a Cuban state-run organization. While too early for us to hypothesize the significance of this (PBSV’s has yet to generate meaningful revenue from Cuba), the OFAC license may provide PBSV with (at least) foot-in-the-door opportunity to a country that has been largely off-limits to most American companies (with some exceptions). And the recently restored (at least formally restored) diplomatic relations between the U.S. and Cuba and potential that sanctions are reduced in the future may mean that this foot-in-the-door could eventually result in even greater opportunity for PBSV (this is wait-and-see status, however, given indications by President Trump that he may reinstate limited access to Cuba).

Model Update…
We have updated our model following Q1 2018 results. We think there may be some incremental additional hurricane related revenue impact, although the relatively muted disruption to Q4 ’17 and Q1 ’18 results and the company’s recovery leads us to believe that this should be fairly short-lived. PBSV’s more rapid and robust recovery relative to our expectations has prompted upward revisions to our modeled revenue. We now model PR consulting revenue growth of 3% in 2018, revised from 9% contraction. We have total revenue increasing 7.5%, revised from 7.7% decrease.

And while we had previously forecasted gross margin to incrementally contract in 2018, the upward revisions to revenue has also benefitted our margins – we now look for GM of 25.5% in 2018, revised up from 23.2% previously. PBSV cost-containment efforts have had a significant and positive impact to profitability but not at the expense of revenue growth. Even very incremental revenue scaling at these OpEx levels can result in a fairly dramatic benefit to operating income.

We look for revenue to grow at a 4-year CAGR of approximately 13% through 2021. We use an industry PE/G ratio of 1.9x to value PBSV. We look for 2020 EPS of $0.06 which values the company at approximately $1.50/share. The stock currently trades at about $0.50, indicating the shares are trading cheaper than fair value.

We also note that the shares continue to trade well below book value – which was $18.2M, or $0.79/share as of January 31, 2018. Cash balance currently sits at $13.2M, or ~$0.57/share. We think book value should provide a floor on the stock.


SUBSCRIBE TO ZACKS SMALL CAP RESEARCH to receive our articles and reports emailed directly to you each morning. Please visit our website for additional information on Zacks SCR. 

DISCLOSURE: Zacks SCR has received compensation from the issuer directly or from an investor relations consulting firm, engaged by the issuer, for providing research coverage for a period of no less than one year. Research articles, as seen here, are part of the service Zacks provides and Zacks receives quarterly payments totaling a maximum fee of $30,000 annually for these services. Full Disclaimer HERE.
User ID:
Remember my ID: